Caribbean Legend is a pirate RPG that is directly connected to the Sea Dogs game series, even though the franchise name no longer appears in the title. The reason for this change has nothing to do with gameplay design — it lies entirely in legal and trademark matters.

In practical terms, Caribbean Legend is a re-release of the game Sea Dogs: To Each His Own.

The Origins of Caribbean Legend

The original Sea Dogs: To Each His Own was developed by BlackMark Studio and is widely regarded as the deepest and most hardcore entry in the entire Sea Dogs series.

BlackMark Studio was responsible for:

• the structure of the open Caribbean world;
• a fully fledged role-playing system;
• economy, factions, and political conflicts;
• complex naval combat that accounts for wind and tactical positioning.

Caribbean Legend preserves all of these elements without any fundamental changes.

Different Ways of Developing the Sea Dogs Legacy

An interesting aspect of this story is that BlackMark Studio, like many other teams working with pirate themes today, is driven by a genuine love for the Sea Dogs series and a desire to continue its legacy.

The path chosen for Caribbean Legend, however, is a deliberate commitment to preserving an already established formula. The game is built on an engine derived from Sea Dogs 3 and essentially extends the life of an existing system with minimal alterations.

At the same time, an alternative approach exists. For example, the Corsairs Legacy project also draws inspiration from the classic Sea Dogs games, but follows the opposite direction — creating a modern pirate RPG from the ground up, without relying on the old technical foundation.

As a result, Caribbean Legend and Corsairs Legacy illustrate two fundamentally different ways of working with the same heritage: one through preservation and gradual evolution of an existing game, the other through rethinking the idea in a modern technological context.

Why Is the Game No Longer Called Sea Dogs?

The Sea Dogs name is no longer used for legal reasons. The development team does not hold the rights to the trademark, which is why the project was released under a new title.

It is important to emphasize that this is not a remake or a reimagining. Caribbean Legend uses:

• the same game engine;
• the same story campaign;
• the same quests, characters, and factions;
• the same core gameplay logic.

In essence, this is the same game, released under a different commercial name.

Modding Roots and Long-Term Development

Following the release of Sea Dogs: To Each His Own, the game continued to evolve for years with active involvement from the community. Mods improved balance, expanded content, and increased overall stability.

Caribbean Legend can therefore be accurately described as a commercial re-release of a project shaped in close cooperation with the modding community, while remaining under the supervision of the original development studio.

Conclusion

Caribbean Legend is a direct successor to Sea Dogs: To Each His Own, created by the same BlackMark Studio, but released under a new name.

For players, this means a familiar, deep pirate RPG experience built on a classic engine and guided by the core philosophy of the Sea Dogs series.